I've highly recommended this overlooked medium of story telling on this blog already. Talking about how scientifically it can help stimulate the Brain and make you smarter.
The prior two posts were all about DC Comics based products. And while I have also listened to some more of those (a Batman Death of the Family adaptation, and a Long Halloween one) I figured I should show here how I've checked out some beyond that.
I of course years ago listened to the Orson Wells War of The Worlds broadcast. It was entertaining, I don't have much to comment on about it.
I listened to much of the Radio Drama adaptation of Isaac Asimov's Foundation series, up to the Mule. I stopped there only because the story doesn't interest me as much once the Second Foundation stuff starts. It's a good adaptation and I highly recommend it.
I also listened to and really enjoyed The Domino Lady All's Fair in War, fans of old Pulp Style stories should enjoy that.
I also listened to a Radio Play version of Carmilla, and it was great, the best adaptation of Carmilla thus far.
For the remainder of this post I want to talk about Rob Skiba's Seed The Series. I just listened to the three Radio Drama episodes he has produced for it, which are supposed to equate to about half the eventual Live Action Pilot.
Rob Skiba is a controversial figure But still I like Rob Skiba and I would like his project to succeed. But I have a tendency to be disappointed by Christian Fiction, so I worry.
I try to keep my criticism independent of my Interpretations of The Bible being different, after all I enjoy endless fiction from people who don't revere The Bible at all. The entire lore Rob has constructed for this is built on assumptions I have come to reject, chiefly the vilification of Nimrod, but also the Hybrid theory itself. But still since I actually enjoy stories that are Gnostic Allegories (like Utena and to an extent SAO), all of that is stuff I can accept.
So Spoilers ahead.
The main character is bland, and I'm generally not into such military centric fiction, it's an incredibly cliche approach for a work of Western Fiction. And having so little from any Female Characters thus far does not endear me either.
This is nitpicky, but I can't help but notice that Rob seems to have forgotten when the U.S. entered Iraq. This is dated to late 2002, the invasion was in spring 2003. Maybe most people don't remember the build up to that war as vividly as I do, but for me that's a slight immersion breaker. Of course my right criticism Anachronisms is fortified since I wrote The Piano Maidens.
I myself as an aspiring writer have a tendency to do things like have my characters make Ghostbusters references, one of my favorite Animes is Lucky Star, that's what I like. But the references made here were awfully generic and predictable.
Still, issues aside there is plenty of potential. When he eventually records more I'll listen to em. And I think these little Radio Plays could be very entertaining to someone who's tastes are different then mine.
Given the stated premise I'd heard from him about this before, about it being called Seed because he wants to start with small seeds and grow from there. I do feel like he's started a little too big. Meeting an actual Fallen Angel in the first episode is a pretty fully grown Tree I think. And if he thinks viewers outside The Church (he said he wants it to have broad appeal.) aren't gonna get the Biblical References right away, he's grossly underestimating them. Of course what he means by the references to Orion is fairly Esoteric.
I'm not saying it's a good idea to do a full bait and switch, make it seem not Christian at all only to suddenly go BAM here is a barrage of Bible Quotes.
I would use characters leading relatively normal lives. In fact I'd do a High School drama, Western audiences look down on those often but I don't care. I love, Buffy, Smallville, Spiderman, One Tree Hill, Pretty Little Liars and endless High School set Anime.
I'd have one main character who's a Christian interpreting what's going on to fit her Biblical World View, but hold off on showing anything to solidly verify her view is correct. Make her have to actually have Faith.
And before encountering actual Old Ones, I'd build the supernatural aspects up more slowly. I'd have Mages who practice Hermetic Magick. Why favor Hermetic Magick? Partly because I love Fate/Stay Night and Fate/Zero and like how it looks there. And also partly because of how much I have enjoyed listening to the claims of William Schnoebelen about things like Transyuggothian Magick. And I'd have at least one of them claiming to be an immortal Alchemist in the tradition of Saint-Germain, Cagliostro and Althotas.
Basically, I'd start the show with the paranormal aspects being mild, and let it build up over time, a growing sense of escalation.
And of course my main characters would all be Lesbians.